Replica By the Fireplace by Maison Margiela is an eau de toilette that opens on pink pepper, orange blossom and clove and settles into vanilla, peru balsam and cashmeran. It reads mostly warm, sweet and woody on our scent profile, at a moderate strength. Its least common notes on our list are chestnut and guaiac wood, in the warm & spicy family. Below are the closest on our list. Similar isn't identical, so try a sample before a full bottle if you can.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It doesn't change your price.
In the same spirit
The 10 closest in the collection
Closest first. The percent is how alike two fragrances are on our scent profile (their notes and their mix of fresh, floral, sweet, woody and warm), not a rating.
- 64%
1.Diptyque
Eau DuelleSimilar · Eau de parfum · For anyone
Both have vanilla and pink pepper.
From $260 for 75 ml (2.5 oz)
- 60%
2.Chanel
ÉgoïsteSimilar · Eau de toilette · For men · 1990
Both have vanilla and clove.
Price at retailer
- 59%
3.Byredo
BibliothèqueSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For anyone
Both have vanilla.
From $235 for 50 ml (1.7 oz)
- 58%
4.Mancera
Red TobaccoSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For anyone · 2017
Both have vanilla.
From $135 for 60 ml (2 oz)
- 57%
5.Armani
Stronger With You IntenselySomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For men
Both have vanilla and pink pepper.
From $105 for 50 ml (1.7 oz)
- 56%
6.Amouage
GuidanceSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For anyone
Both have vanilla.
From $395 for 100 ml (3.4 oz)
- 55%
7.Amouage
Jubilation XXV ManSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For men
Both have guaiac wood and clove.
From $395 for 100 ml (3.4 oz)
- 55%
8.Tom Ford
Lost CherrySomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For women · 2018
Both have vanilla and clove.
From $265 for 30 ml (1 oz)
- 54%
9.Bvlgari
Man in BlackSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For men · 2014
Both have guaiac wood.
From $148 for 60 ml (2 oz)
- 52%
10.Valentino
Donna Born in RomaSomewhat similar · Eau de parfum · For women
Both have vanilla and cashmeran.
From $110 for 30 ml (1 oz)
Not quite it?
Tell us what you love, and what you never wear.
We'll match you with the fragrances that fit, with a % match for each.